211 reviews
All reviews (211)
Yelp (14)
Google (197)
Newest First
Newest First
Oldest First
Highest Rated
Lowest Rated
Nathan Krauth
2 years ago
Pretty dirty. The staff was friendly but not very helpful answering questions. They don’t have a lot of selection for pet habitat supplies. I felt bad for the animals because of their cramped conditions. There are much better local pet shops in Milwaukee that keep their pets in comfortable living areas. Not a place I’d have interest in going back to.
Patricia Dominguez
2 years ago
Friendly service! All of my questions were, patiently, answered by staff. They have reasonable prices, too. There are a decent selection of products to care for reptiles (if you have any, of course!) ????????????????
A C
2 years ago
Great place, very caring staff with the clients and animals and very informative and helpful, always go here due to there honesty on caring and selling products and animals.
Jason “Casper D” Herrmann
2 years ago
Greatest pet store in Bayview I've been going there for 30 years and bought all my snakes from Gary
Caleb Andrew
3 years ago
Give Tom his money you coward
G R
3 years ago
Idk who Tom is but he wants his money now
Jerod Schroeder
3 years ago
Good selection. Friendly staff. Support local small businesses. It's a fun place to look around.
Jonathan Torgeson
3 years ago
Where's Tom's money? We commiting wage theft these days for the fun of it or do you just lack the self respect to pay your employees?
Kathleen Michel
3 years ago
Friendly, patient, knowledgeable people work here. I visited there with my grandkids who are interested in reptiles. They're researching how to care for them, but are still in preliminary stage. They learned about costs and animal requirements. No pressure. Very positive experience for the kids.
Miranda Milonczyk
3 years ago
Always nice and quick service.
Niall Brady
3 years ago
Doesn’t pay their employees. Have a friend who works here, has worked 6 hours for a total of 22 days and Gary owes him $816. Where’s the money Gary?
Terrell Rosenberg
3 years ago
Where is Tom’s wages? Are they a myth? I’m confused.
Jon Gregory
3 years ago
Now open Monday - Friday 11am - 5pm. I suppose that is a step up from by appointment only & one customer at a time.
nathan mata
3 years ago
Selection of reptiles is trash store is way to small if ur looking to buy a reptile don't come here it's a waste of time pet smart has a bigger selection of reptiles then this place
CreepyFoxxx
3 years ago
Always have what i need for my ball python.
John G Russell Jr
3 years ago
Awesome service owner is knows his business big time its worth the effort
Bradly Schmidt
3 years ago
The best place to get Millet in the Milwaukee area.
Maxwell Sauer
3 years ago
They have a fish. Its green and almost dead!?
Travis Hope
3 years ago
Great service in the neighborhood with a large variety of what you need to take care of your pet or get a new one
Jay Duffy
3 years ago
Gary's Pet Shop is the Go-To place for all of your pet needs or wants. I personally received my ball python from Gary's 11 years ago and only go to Gary's for the live rats that I feed to her. Walking space can be tight but that is only due to the vast options of supplies, pets, and everything that they need. Gary caries it all!
Honee Lee
3 years ago
My husband has been going there since he was a kid.
Marsha Zay
3 years ago
I love this place, it's the only place I go to get food for my bearded dragon
Mike Walker
3 years ago
Staff was very helpful and friendly. I love my new ball pythons.
Brad Benike
4 years ago
Always a great story to visit. Friendly and knowledgeable staff. Highly recommend them
Rainy Rae
4 years ago
Jeff, Mindi, Victoria & Gary are absolutely wonderful to work with and deal with.
queen shelly
4 years ago
They didnt have crickets and their mices were smart????they chewed threw a box a paper bag and a plastic bag while i was omw home
Ann Treptow
4 years ago
We were in there yesterday and bought the pied ball, he is such a sweetheart and the service was amazing.
arthur scroggins
4 years ago
Privately owned. Staff knowledgeable. A little cramped but a good place for reptiles tarantulas.
Rocky
4 years ago
For the past 10 years gary has never let me down, great prices and always has what a need.
Cali Chicana
4 years ago
Everything I need for my crested gecko
show more reviews
Business Hours
Monday
10 AM - 8 PM
Tuesday
10 AM - 8 PM
Wednesday
10 AM - 8 PM
Thursday
10 AM - 8 PM
Friday
10 AM - 8 PM
Saturday
10 AM - 5 PM
Sunday
12 PM - 5 PM
Popular Hours
Monday
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Thursday
Friday
Saturday
Sunday
Is this your business?