Pet Supplies Plus Evanston Evanston, Illinois

205 reviews

Book an appointment

Online booking unavailable.

Please call

(847) 868-8331



*with JustAnswer

Reviews: Pet Supplies Plus Evanston (Evanston)

All reviews (205)

Yelp (36)

Google (169)

Newest First

Newest First

Oldest First

Highest Rated

Lowest Rated

Adam Lebin

2 years ago

great neighborhood pet store. The redfords store brand cat and dog food is a great product. Quick delivery as well.

jay friedman

2 years ago

I called and made an appointment for 2:30 today, for trimming my dog's nails. I got there at 2:25 and waited until 2:40 while the staff tried to locate the groomer, with no success. Good thing I called for an appointment, huh. Thanks for nothing.

Alli B

2 years ago

Probably the nicest and biggest pet supply plus I've seen, they had the hamster bedding I needed and were friendly, and I got asked if I needed any help so very attentive. Only issue I saw was that I saw some hamsters they had there that looked like they didn't have wheels to run on and that's a necessity for them

Rudy Bless

2 years ago

Super helpful and friendly staff, and really great prices on pet food! I get coupons for a considerable amount off pretty regularly with the loyalty / rewards program too!

Lynda Combes

2 years ago

Associates are always nice and helpful. Prices are decent and they have a great selection of inventory.

Esther Westlake

2 years ago

I've had good experiences at every Pet Supplies Plus store, but this is still the best one in the area. Manager and staff are nice people, and they always have my cat's food in stock.

Brent Mccollum

2 years ago

Required masks before mandate took effect.


2 years ago

This store was very clean and spotless.


2 years ago

Visited here for the first time 2 days ago on the suggestion of a friend and I'm very glad I did. I was given advice when I was unsure of a purchase, my dog loved it there (of course) and I will be back soon!

Darlene Davis

2 years ago

Don't have a groomer but they need one it's allot of dogs living out there

Darlene Goebel

2 years ago

Very happy with the service

Rainy Rae

2 years ago

Todd made me feel like a million bucks. Jofie and Regie will forever be therapy animals with me ♡

Sydney Zimelis

2 years ago

This store goes above and beyond to get this (now) loyal customer(s) dog food prepped and delivered - thanks so much for being accommodating and proactive!

Blue Man Sal

2 years ago

Lot's of pet supplies,great customer service and very knowledgeable people.

jeff wood

2 years ago

They have all tour pet needs and frendly service

Nickie C

2 years ago

They don’t do price match + coupon, unlike the PSPs in Lincolnwood and Lakeview who do so without question. I tried to explain to the 2 owners that they were violating corporate policy and possibly the law. When they kept being unreasonable, I told them they had lost a customer for life. However, they do have a nice clean spacious bathroom. So I might stop in to use that only.

Angela O'Brien

2 years ago

indeed I prefer PSP over major chains. this location is always clean, well stocked and associates are helpful and friendly.

J E Kaufman

2 years ago

I love shopping online and then picking up the order curbside. It is amazingly convenient. The folks who work at Pet Supplies Plus Evanston are *very* friendly, efficient, and are excellent at staying in touch about when my order is ready. Big thanks to them!

Judy Koon

2 years ago

Friendly place to get dog food and supplies.

Kathy Kearns

2 years ago

Nice customer service. Good prices and amazing selection

Mario Yarbrough

2 years ago

The manager is really kind and polite.

Mark Barron

2 years ago

Found everything I needed. Had to wait a while for check out.

Sandy Weller

2 years ago

Owner is great. There always seems to be at least one of anything I’m looking for on the shelf. Prices are comparable. Self service dog wash is a good deal too.


3 years ago

We received personal service from Tamara, one of the owners. She gave us advice on everything we would need for when we bring our new puppy home. Tamara was very patient and walked us down the aisles to show us where everything was, and made recommendations based on the approximate size and breed. We’ve been using them for our bird, so we knew it would be an excellent place to go. It is obvious that everyone there loves animals!

Jeanette Cotledge

3 years ago

The owner and manager of this place is very customer focus, friendly, and really cares about their customers and their customers pets! I highly recommend shopping here for U Pet Parents!


3 years ago

People are great, very helpful and friendly.

Mary Mendoza

3 years ago

I absolutely love that the owners get to know all of their customers and are so charismatic . You can truly feel the love they have for their patrons and their pets. They also carry items not available at your big box stores at reasonable prices. This store has my business for life!

Dee Mixon

3 years ago

Great service and variety every time!

rick hamann

3 years ago

Pet Supplies Plus is simply perfect. Large enough to carry anything and everything (I've yet to stump them on a product), yet the staff makes it feel like a neighborhood store. They are attentive and extremely knowledgable. And seem like real pet lovers.

Michael Humphries-Dolnick

3 years ago

Great small business with great service

show more reviews

Pet Supplies Plus Evanston, Illinois, Evanston

1916 Dempster St

Business Hours


9 AM - 7 PM


9 AM - 7 PM


9 AM - 7 PM


9 AM - 7 PM


9 AM - 7 PM


9 AM - 7 PM


9 AM - 6 PM

Is this your business?