Carol's Critters Tallahassee, Florida

303 reviews

Book an appointment

Online booking unavailable.

Please call

(850) 574-6199



*with JustAnswer

Reviews: Carol's Critters (Tallahassee)

All reviews (303)

Yelp (16)

Google (287)

Newest First

Newest First

Oldest First

Highest Rated

Lowest Rated

Sabrina Hayes

2 years ago

Picking up live feeders for the critters is always fun at Carol's. Its fun to look at all the lizards, snakes and other creatures.


2 years ago

Carol has great knowledge of the pets

Christopher Mcbride sr

2 years ago

Beautiful fish at this place.

Kristin B

2 years ago

Such a fantastic shop. Extensive selection for fish and reptile accessories, setups and live pets. Birds, small animals and their feed products are everywhere too! Prices can't be beat. The staff are so helpful and nice. Clean and organized - you can really tell that care goes into not just what products they choose to carry on the shelves but also what they use in their own aquatic setups in place - they wouldn't sell you what they wouldn't use and that's something I can get behind. **December 2021 Update: I've seen other reviews about rudeness from the staff, curt attitudes from Carol and misinformation regarding pet care and instructions. While each scenario is different, my own experiences at Carol's have been different. Maybe 1 staff member came across as curt to me once but I chalked it up to their youth. Another 4, including Carol, have taken time out on numerous occasions to help me with products, tank crises I was having on a few occasions and if they did not know an answer, they said as much. Its up to pet owners to know their pets, not the shop selling it to instruct them or hand hold us in taking care of our animals, so while I know not all elements are within everyone's control, I can speak to my experiences with my purchases of products and livestock that Carol's Critters helped me whenever called upon.

Jeffrey Hatcher

2 years ago

Knowledgeable staff. They are helpful and have good advice since they have pets of their own. Good selection of quality animals. Well cared for.

James Bond

2 years ago

Very nice ppl helped me out with my bearded

Emily Thomas

2 years ago

Absolutely the most knowledgeable crew at any pet store in town and in surrounding areas!

Damian Borrelli

2 years ago

Great local shop for your pet's needs

Casey Robertson

2 years ago

Great fish store. Awesome selection.

Amanda M

2 years ago

Small not what I expected. Vert friendly service.

A Google user

2 years ago

I was very excited to get a pacman frog but the young woman working was very rude. You can be informative without being condescending. I’m happy with my new frog but unfortunately this experience has lead me to shop elsewhere.

Alison S

2 years ago

Best pet store in Tallahassee. Only local freshwater fish store

Brittany Derry

2 years ago

Great experience here. Good customer service. I got my cockateil here, and they are SO sweet. You can tell they were well attended to. Very happy customer. I went to 4 different pet stores before coming here. None of them were as good as this place. Pic is day one of my baby coming home and settling in.

Madora Mantooth

2 years ago

Good quality service and great place to shop for your critters.

vi vi

2 years ago

A bit of a crowded space but that's not their fault, I got my russian tortoise from here and I'm extremely satisfied with her :)

Tip Smith

2 years ago

This place here does not even deserve a star! They sold my female ferret I put a deposit on and didn’t even have an explanation. All the manager could say was idk what happened you can choose from what we have now or we’ll give your deposit back in store credit! Now who the heck would want store credit when they’re already disappointed in your service? SMH…they should do better especially when it is they’re mess up.

Linda Fitzpatrick

2 years ago

Good products for dogs. Can get what you need and the people working there are helpful and really nice. I love that they have their dogs there where you pay.


2 years ago

A little pricey... But, overall the staff is knowledgeable and helpful.

yolanda alford

2 years ago

I love this place and have been going here for years. Its my go to for all my fish needs.

emily williams

2 years ago

I love Carol and her staff! Very knowledgeable and friendly! Go check it out!

Eric Felton

2 years ago

The most helpful staff on the planet

Jasmine Mcvicker

2 years ago

Friendly staff and happy animals :)

John W

2 years ago

We have been frequently going into Carol's Critters since moving to Tallahassee in May. They have such a unique selection of aquatic and reptile pets to look at and purchase. We have now purchased multiple fish and a hedgehog from Carol's! The staff are very friendly and knowledgeable and we will continue to come here solely for their expertise. I highly recommend Carol's Critters.

Mickie Smith

2 years ago

Never seems to have what I am looking for...staff is not very engaging.

Tabor Buckland

2 years ago

This place is so cool! And, all of the different animals are amazing, and the employees are so helpful!

Kathybeth Geigel

2 years ago

I love the place because the help us with everything about the fish

Chelle Christensen

2 years ago

Great place to go for pets, pet supplies and information about both!! Cutest little ferrets EVER!!

Tyffany Douglas

2 years ago

Carols critters is a cute little pet store packed with all kinds of supplies as well as fish & reptiles. Clean and organized & GREAT PRICES! It's an hour drive for me but I will continue to get all my supplies from Carol's critters. I could tell by the parking lot they were popular, the store had customers coming and going lol.

Carolyn Blue

2 years ago

Small, local pet store. Great aquarium selection; lots of fish! Friendly, helpful, knowledgeable staff.

Dawn Jackson

2 years ago

LOVED LOVED CAROLS CRITTERs! Staff very knowledgeable about the animals! Will most definitely be back!

show more reviews

Carol's Critters, Florida, Tallahassee

2401 W Pensacola St

Business Hours


10 AM - 7 PM


10 AM - 7 PM


10 AM - 7 PM


10 AM - 7 PM


10 AM - 7 PM


10 AM - 7 PM


12 PM - 5 PM

Is this your business?