Animal Pantry West Babylon, New York

156 reviews

Book an appointment

Online booking unavailable.

Please call

(631) 983-8347



*with JustAnswer

Reviews: Animal Pantry (West Babylon)

All reviews (156)

Yelp (24)

Google (132)

Newest First

Newest First

Oldest First

Highest Rated

Lowest Rated

Deborah Maffettone

2 years ago

Always has what I need, prices are better than anywhere, and I love shopping local and seeing Dawn who is always there to greet everyone. The staff is friendly and so very helpful.

Donna Borgesano

2 years ago

My husband comes to this store often. He has pleased been with the variety of cat food that he has been able to find here because the supermarkets hav been able to keep Purina cat food in stock.

Violet Blossoms

2 years ago

I've been going to this location for a year or two now and every time I'm there it's a great experience. The staff are very nice and caring and or always willing to help you. Since I don't have a pet of my own, I usually go there to visit the cats the place has rescued and pet or play with them. From how they behave and look, they have been clearly given love, nutrition, attention, and care. Sometimes I even got to help with the cats since I've always wanted to adopt one someday and the staff know me well enough to know how much I love doing it and they trust me. Overall, this is a really nice pet store for the variety of pet food and supplies available, the caring and helpful staff, and how clear it is that all of the cats are being taken care of. I would highly recommend this place!

Brandon Romano

2 years ago

Great neighborhood pet store, usually have everything you need for the kids, pets. I like the cool cats hanging around the store...

W Chance

2 years ago

They have every pet food you can imagine! Great prices. Great staff. We have been shopping here often, not just for pet supplies, but also to visit all the great cats they have walking around. The owner, Dawn, is amazing and caring. She has helped to save countless cats. We wholeheartedly support her business. You should, too!

Debra McDonald

2 years ago

Dawn was awesome! Couldn't be happier?

Dylan Calero

2 years ago

They have cats everywhere and I absolutely love that.

Eddie Calli

2 years ago

Great place. Don't keep the door open, watch for roaming kitties!

Edith Post

2 years ago

Went for dry cat food. Good selection on all kinds of pet supplies.

Mat and Ameera Zoller

2 years ago

Love the customer service here, especially when Emmaline or Shakira say my order should be free!!! Lol ????????????

Roe E

2 years ago

Friendly staff Nice variety of four legged children food, toys, and accessories

Jeannine Simpson

2 years ago

The staff is very friendly and helpful. They have multiple colonies of feral cats that they have inside the store that they feed and provide shelter and health care to.

M Mills

2 years ago

Good store. Prices are reasonable, good selection of products, some higher quality products which I like. What I really like is how they give back by allowing a cat rescue have a few cats that for people to see & adopt. They also have "house cats" that have a permanent home there. Thumbs up!

Sandra Perfetto

2 years ago

It was a positive experience. I've never seen so much pet food in one place. A young man helped us, his name is Matt. He is very knowledgeable and helped us with our choice..

Diana Narizzano

2 years ago

Dawn is the best, she is very knowledgeable on how to keep your pets happy and healthy! Love this place ❤????????????

Ingrid Hauri

2 years ago

You can play with the cats while you shop. Perfect for cat lovers.

judith lawrence

2 years ago

Good prices lots of veriaty and if you're looking for a cat they have plenty.

Sam sam

2 years ago

Nice people working here. They always offer to help and have a great supply of different cat foods. If you have a fussy kitty this is the place to go ! Also , there is kitten rescue thing at front of store … loads of kittens to see! Lastly, the store has cats that live in the store … shout out to the fierce fat tabby and white girl kitty , always lays by back door … I think her name is Aberleene ? Anyhow , she’s cute and tuff! Oh , they got a few Betta fish hanging out for sale. Lot of the betta set ups their selling are way too small tho. Betta need minimum 5 gallons , heater and filter to lead their best lives!

Banu Bor

2 years ago

Very helpful and friendly staff.

Tony Skiadas

2 years ago

Live the kitties walking around the shop! They have everything you need, go check it out!

Mathew Zoller

3 years ago

This is WAY MORE than a pet store. They take in animals in need, they adopt out animals, they genuinely care about ALL animals. They even have a network of caring people that will do everything in their power to help you find your lost pet. I'm sure I'm leaving something out, and I could go on and on, but if you love animals you'll definitely stop going to the warehouse pet stores after one visit.

Sandra Vercillo

3 years ago

Love this store! Love supporting small businesses! Carries all foods I feed both dogs and cats. Very amazing helpful staff. All around wonderful!

Margarette Wahl

3 years ago

I usually shop at the Farmingdale location, but West Babylon is as welcoming.

Eva Fer

3 years ago

Nice staff,always shop here food for our dog,so helpful the reward program; for every 10 bags of food we get 1 free.

George Palomino Jr (El Maniatiko)

3 years ago

Awesome Place for My Animals Food and Snacks. Awesome Peeps.

Jay V

3 years ago

great Holistic place with roaming cats!! caring staff!!

Jeanine Fox

3 years ago

Staff is friendly helpful and if you can't find it or they don't have it, ask they'll get it. 98% of the time, lol prices are comparable. Has own parking in back wheelchair accessible


3 years ago

I loved this store.Here is now my local pet store. We bought cat litter from there yesterday.Me and my husband asked for cat how was this cat litter.Cat say meow good cat litter.Me and my husband are favorite store now.Because too many cat inside.Cat say welcome to store. Me and my husband cat lover.????????????????.Employee friendly too. I am shopping this store until this time for my cat needs. I support my local pet store and shopping there.

Tom Zim

3 years ago

The animals seem happy and healthy and are absolutely adorable


3 years ago

I love animal pantry! Great selection and prices, store kitties, as well as beautiful kitties for adoption. The staff is usually very helpful, and I've never had a bad experience in all my years of shopping there

show more reviews

Animal Pantry, New York, West Babylon

620 Sunrise Hwy

Business Hours


10 AM - 8 PM


10 AM - 8 PM


10 AM - 8 PM


10 AM - 8 PM


10 AM - 8 PM


10 AM - 6 PM


11 AM - 5 PM

Is this your business?