Pets Warehouse Selden, New York

84 reviews

Book an appointment

Online booking unavailable.

Please call

(631) 732-9050



*with JustAnswer

Reviews: Pets Warehouse (Selden)

All reviews (84)

Yelp (12)

Google (72)

Newest First

Newest First

Oldest First

Highest Rated

Lowest Rated


2 years ago

Friendly staff good prices. Always seem to have what I need

Shaleen Daly

2 years ago

Pleasant and helpful staff. Many options of food for my cat.

Mr. Mayhem

2 years ago

Overpriced but conveniently located I guess that’s what you’re paying for.

Wesam H

2 years ago

Staff is super helpful and you have many options for your furry friends. Prices are also fair. Highly recommend.

Kevin p tunney

2 years ago

They were very well stocked and everything was in a neat order. Quick check out.

Pauline B.

2 years ago

Don’t buy dog food here bag after bag is infested with moths. I complained returned bags and exchanged and each one has moths crawling out after I open the bag.

Susan Kiefer

2 years ago

I love this business. We adopted a large Hound/Yellow Lab-puppy in July 2021. I ventured in to look for bones and squeaky toys, and the WOW factor hit me. They have a Great selection of anything your pet desires. They have a wonderful staff-Polite, and informed. I’ve been back since the first visit and I will be there over the holiday weekend. I would recommend this business to everyone ????

Allister McGuire

2 years ago

Great selection and prices for my cats' food

Christopher Balk

2 years ago

Prices much closer to reasonable than other PETCOmpanies. Seriously, save 20% just shopping here instead. Helpful cashiers and clean.

Elizabeth G

2 years ago

I wish any pet store would carry more pet rat items.

Jamie Miller

2 years ago

I love pets Warehouse, that really good prices and have everything you need for your pets. But at this location the staff wasn't too knowledgeable on the animals and care

Jacqueline Nicole Grazidei

3 years ago

I Love the Pet Warehouse, the people that work there are so friendly and honest, and are willing to go the extra mile for us pet lovers. i added 2 pictures of my baby boy Rroxx and his babies from the pet ware house, plus i love how clean and protective they are since covid...

Khadija Robbins

3 years ago

I hate to walk into an establishment and not be met with a greeting. I had to come find help while the two associates stood up front talking to each only have one associate stare at me with a blank face and not even answer so the other had to jump in. Needless to say I will NEVER spend my money there ever again!

Ibelle Casanas

3 years ago

Great Neighborhood Pet Store. Great Selection!! Great Price Points!!

Keith Bettencourt

3 years ago

Great place for a quick stop for everything for your pups

S Smith

3 years ago

I was disappointed because as a "warehouse" I don't understand how they do not have interactive dog games/toys but have many to choose from for cats. ????


3 years ago

Large selection - knowledgeable staff - good prices.

Michael Banks

3 years ago

Have everything I need for my rabbit

Stephanie Parise

3 years ago

I have a large variety of pet food and treats. They also have a small aquatic section. They are a bit pricey on their pet food and treats.

Shawn OBrien

3 years ago

Ownership should know that I received an email from their company that actually called me a “dirtbag”. Great customer service. I will be happy to share the email with anyone thinking of doing business with this company.

Samuel Orellana

3 years ago

Was on my way to another pet store and noticed this pets warehouse on the way and stopped by. Note: anyone looking for live animals, this pets warehouse doesn't have any livestock at the time of my visit. Not out of stock, simply no animals so if you enjoy cruising through fish and other pets for sale, be aware you won't find that here. This is honestly the only reason I knocked off one star since every other pets warehouse I'd been to has pets. Purchased a small item for my aquarium at the best price from any physical store I'd been to. Staff was friendly as well.

Ryan D

3 years ago

You get a better variety and price at Petsmart

Michael Lack

3 years ago

Great quality pet store and priced fair. Could use some more toys made in U.S.A , more pet toys with made with 100% safe materials, and some more pet food with all natural ingredients designed for proven longevity and healthier.

deborah olmstead

3 years ago

My new favorite pet store! Great variety and the best prices anywhere!!! Found the same Kong toy that I paid 18.00 for at Petco for 9.00 here. Great selection of toys and treats.

Kreiger D

3 years ago

Always showed here. Love it . 10/10 wow

Kathy Cybulski

3 years ago

Always have what I need And good prices

Jaay Smith

3 years ago

When I entered store, employee ask if I need help.The employee was very helpful and knowledgeable.

Deborah Scalcione

3 years ago

Love their prices and that they're well stocked!

Beth Miller

3 years ago

I buy the Wellness brand for my elderly doggie. Wish the price was a bit lower ... But what can you do.

Mary Cubano

3 years ago

I am a frequent shopper in the selden new york store but that may change. I went into the store today with my 7 year old grandson and there was a big black dog that came up to us in the aisle we were in. I yelled for the owner who happened to be in the next aisle and he called the dog. When i went to check out he was approaching the check out area also and the dog came up to us. I asked him to call the dog. There was another small dog properly leashed and i removed myself and grandson from the area as i thought they were going to fight. All this while your employees said nothing to him about the dog being off leash. There is a leash law correct? I will probably find another store to get my pet supplies from in the future.

show more reviews

Pets Warehouse, New York, Selden

291 Middle Country Rd

Is this your business?