Amwell Pet Supply Hillsborough, New Jersey

67 reviews

Book an appointment

Online booking unavailable.

Please call

(908) 359-5117



*with JustAnswer

Reviews: Amwell Pet Supply (Hillsborough)

All reviews (67)

Yelp (18)

Google (49)

Newest First

Newest First

Oldest First

Highest Rated

Lowest Rated

Suzanne Vescovi

2 years ago

Hope is very knowledgeable and helpful. Quality products and great customer service. Shopping small business is the way to go. Personalized service each and every time.

Paige Sciarrillo

2 years ago

We adopted our rabbit from AARG and we are so incredibly grateful for the work that they do. They are extremely knowledgeable and take excellent care of their animals. They prioritize finding a safe home and educating owners on how to best care for their new pets. I highly recommend adopting from them.

M. Correa

2 years ago

Most of the stuff is pricy but I'm giving 5 stars because the ladies who work there are so nice! Plus, let's support our local businesses instead the million dollar companies. I've only been there once but I would return. Anyone looking to adopt a cat they have beautiful cats/kittens there as well.

Lynn K

2 years ago

Great place to adopt a kitty! Hope was so nice to work with.

Elizabeth Arent

2 years ago

Hope was so helpful and sweet! The shop is clean and you can tell the staff really cares about all their animals.

Janice L

2 years ago

They are always there to answer any questions you might have. If your looking to adopt they have cats, kittens. And just about anything you would need for your pets.

Maddy Graves

2 years ago

Had to surrender my dear hamster JJ to Amwell today and I couldn’t have made the better choice of where to surrender him too!! Hope and the volunteers really do care about the animals and I can see I left him in the best possible hands. I wish JJ luck in finding a new home and to all the other beautiful animals. Thank you so much, Hope! I hope to repay you in the future.

Allison Diaz

2 years ago

Love this place! Very friendly customer service!

Robert Mennella

2 years ago

Empathetic caring place. Please adopt today.

Cheryl Graziano

2 years ago

Great service and American made toys ! Full selection of all pet needs

Michele Kidd

2 years ago

The staff makes the store! Always so knowledgeable and helpful. Sometimes we you need to be patient if there's a few people in there, but between that and the quality products I know I'm doing what's right for my cats!

Family Bisignano

2 years ago

We just adopted a sweet baby bunny from here and have adopted our past 2 from Amwell Pet Supply. They do an amazing job of rescuing and taking care of animals. It is always a pleasure shopping at the store and Hope and staff are helpful and Knowledgeable!

Morgan Zink

2 years ago

Hope was so amazing and helpful with my situation. I have my two babies (guinea pigs) which I’m no longer able to take care of because of health reasons and she took them with no problem and assured me they will go to a good home. I miss my babies but I know she’ll find them a good home. Thank you so much!

Kayla Rizzo

3 years ago

What an amazing place! They really care about all animals! And have absolutely everything u could ever need for an animal! I would highley rcommend adopting from there. All of there animals r friendly. I cant imagine going to another pet store. Go check it out! U wont be disapointed :)

Michelina Aichele

3 years ago

Amwell pet supply is hands down the best pet store in Somerset county. Not only is the staff super personable and helpful, but the store is always well stocked and the rescue work they do is a God send. Highly recommend shopping, donating, and volunteering here. They are amazing.

Keith Monsell

3 years ago

Very polite and extremely helpful! I highly recommend visiting this pet shop to adopt a pet and for your pet food, toys, treats etc. Extremely helpful and you won't find more fair pricing!

Joseph Smith

3 years ago

The owner is so sweet and knowledgeable. Nice to have a smalle Hometown pet store that you could talk to somebody and they also remember you

nika s

3 years ago

Very good pet store! Very friendly and helpful service!


3 years ago

It is an amazing pet supply store, they have everything you need and also they have some very well taken care of animals.

Sue Todoroff

3 years ago

They are so helpful. You won't get that in the big chains. Thank you


3 years ago

The have types of bird food that you don't find at the major chain pet stores.

Nancy mueller

3 years ago

We adopted two guinea pigs from Amwell Pet Supply. Hope and Dawn were so helpful from the get go. They were both so knowledgeable and it's obvious how much they care for all the animals. The piggies are so happy and healthy. The store was great, too. Good quality products and Dawn was very open and honest with her recommendations.

Laury Vaden

3 years ago

My go to pet supply! Helpful! Great service!

Hello There

3 years ago

Was a bit upset that I wasn't even greeted when entering as the employee was glued to her phone. Other than that plenty of food selections. Also very nice to see that they have many resident pets that live in store.

Erica Golubiewski

3 years ago

Love this store. Good prices too

Debjani Sahu

3 years ago

They have a great selection of pet fishes, besides pet rabbits, guinea pigs, birds. The store lady was so polite and helped us very nicely. They keep wide variety of tropical, betta, and gold fishes. Only silly thing is they don’t keep male and female fishes separate.

Crystal R.

3 years ago

Absolutely love Amwell Pet supply! Small business locally owned. The owner, Hope, is such an angel. She truly cares about all animals. She is very knowledgeable and can help you with all your pet care needs. We have been shopping here for about 3 yrs and have always had a pleasant experience. Selection of items here is quite large. They carry the brand Fromm, which is a great brand and the brand we feed our fur baby, Rosie. I highly suggest shopping local and supporting this small business.

Alex Fernandez

3 years ago

Lovely, amazing staff that want the best for their pets.

Emily Keller

4 years ago

The people here are fantastic. The staff really care about the animals they have for adoption and are a fount of knowledge.

George Brzozowski

4 years ago

Very friendly people and helpful

show more reviews

Amwell Pet Supply, New Jersey, Hillsborough

434 Rt 206 S

Business Hours


9 AM - 8 PM


9 AM - 8 PM


9 AM - 8 PM


9 AM - 8 PM


9 AM - 8 PM


9 AM - 6 PM


10 AM - 5 PM

Is this your business?