Pet Supplies Plus - Bayville Bayville, New Jersey

158 reviews

Book an appointment

Online booking unavailable.

Please call

(732) 269-1896



*with JustAnswer

Reviews: Pet Supplies Plus - Bayville (Bayville)

All reviews (158)

Yelp (3)

Google (155)

Newest First

Newest First

Oldest First

Highest Rated

Lowest Rated

Tim Jordan

2 years ago

Nice place, lots of stuff.

Debbie Stoner

2 years ago

Oliver looks amazing!! Thank you!!❤

Frank and Carol Gialanella

2 years ago

Staff is knowledgeable and very friendly! Great selection. Love this store!!

shealyn manning

2 years ago

I don't leave reviews often but absolutely had to today. I shop here for pet supplies often and always in store and have never had a bad experience. The pet supplies perks card has saved me money here and there many times in the year or two I've been coming here. They've been friendly to my very energetic pit that comes in with me occasionally and love to give out little treats to her when they're not busy. Today I'm leaving my review specifically to mention an employee there named Anna. I am not feeling well and did not want to go in store as a precautionary step but was down to my last scoop of food for my pup. I tried ordering curbside online but had trouble with the payment being accepted. Anna was the associate who helped me when I called to place the order on the phone and went out of her way to come to my car to grab my payment and then brought the big dog food bag out to my trunk so I wouldn't have to go inside. The team here is always helpful and friendly. I'd recommend this pet store to anybody in the area. ????????????????????

Sally Potter

2 years ago

Fanflippintastic ❤ They have all your pets needs...always stocked...always Sheba loves going in the store with me and seeing all the other dogs she thinks she's at the dog park...lmao

Angela Bradach

2 years ago

Staff is always helpful and friendly

michal alegre

2 years ago

They took amazing care of my dog. She was groomed and de shedded and they did an amazing job ???????????? they took great care of my dog ????. And will be coming back again

Patty Baumgardt

2 years ago

The store was very clean and had everything I needed for my pets. The workers are very helpful.

Stacy Fretta

2 years ago

The staff could not be more helpful but supplies are limited

Patrick Shields

2 years ago

Okay so this is one of those big pet stores you go in and they have everything you need and you can take your dog there and wash it yourself and they have all the Pet Foods pet snacks toys and you can bring your animal in there and walk around the girls are very helpful and they have such an inventory stocked at usually every time I go in there they have what I need and the service the atmosphere and the girls that work there they're fantastic thumbs up

Scott McIntyre

2 years ago

Decent pet store. Nothing special.

Kimberly Nardone

2 years ago

Had everything I needed and the cashier was very knowledgeable and helpful.

TheFour Diamonds

2 years ago

Very nice and sanitary place for all your pet needs along with a place to wash your pets!


2 years ago

My dogs and I only shop there

Basset Mom

2 years ago

Friendly staff, the items I need are in stock, & you offer coupons! Definitely glad I made the switch from Petsmart!

Derek Vinyard

2 years ago

Went here for a simple grooming for my puppy my dog was supposed to be there for 2 hours went back after 1 hour just to check up they have my dog in a cage soaking wet with the air conditioner blasting and my dog is very upset and shivering when I asked the disrespectful worker why this was she laughed and said my puppy was not cooperating so they put her in the cage to calm down without drying her I said this is not a funny situation please don't laugh the girl continued to laugh so I told her just give me my dog and I'll be on my way I got my dog home and washed her and dried her myself it still took her an hour to calm down after this experience she was so upset stay away from this terrible groomer they abuse animals and are no good I will not be returning and I'll tell everyone I know with a pet not to take their animals here for grooming

Jamie Vallone

2 years ago

Groomers, Ali and Lexi were amazing!! They were so living and kind to our pup, who was scared and full of knots prior to her grooming. They both assured my husband and I that our puppy, Brooklyn, was going to be just fine and not to worry. They provided excellent care and were the most amazing people to leave your dog with. Ali and Lexi will now be our new groomers. So impressed. Thank you so much!! You guys couldn’t be in a better profession!!!

Jay Silvestro

2 years ago

Everything our loving pups deserve is here!!!!

Jennifer Koester

2 years ago

They have the dry cat food that I buy from Amazon. So happy about that! Decent prices

L Madden

2 years ago

Possibly the worst pet store I've ever been to. Do not buy pets from here ever, especially if you have kids.

Peggy Melvin

2 years ago

Bayville store is one of the BEST places to get pet supplies! Excellent employees who love your pet when you bring your pet in , helpful in finding products you need and employees who making shopping very pleasant!!!


2 years ago

I love pet supply plus the have most of what i need and at a great price easy and quick service. I always order fish supply's from them.

Desiree DiMartino

2 years ago

Staff was friendly and very helpful...our new go to for pet supplies

Jessica Westdyke

2 years ago

Love this store and the employees ???? ❤

Lauren Papale

2 years ago

So clean in this store. Every staff member is super nice & also informative

Christina Madden

2 years ago

The Staff and store are Excellent

Joshua V

2 years ago

My wife and I were in the bayville store yesterday. We had a few questions for our pet and everyone was so helpful.

Gloria DeLorenzo

3 years ago

Super helpful and friendly staff

Patricia Cali

3 years ago

Love the neighborhood store at Bayville. Plus when I asked about professional grooming services the groomer-in-training let me know about their ears and nails practice and the fact that they (the groomers) would have full certification by the end of July. So friendly and helpful. Cashiers are also very friendly!????????????????????

Lisa Krainski

3 years ago

Love this store and their delivery option is an added bonus! Great customer service all around ♥️

show more reviews

Pet Supplies Plus - Bayville, New Jersey, Bayville

445 Atlantic City Blvd

Business Hours


9 AM - 9 PM


9 AM - 9 PM


9 AM - 9 PM


9 AM - 9 PM


9 AM - 9 PM


9 AM - 9 PM


10 AM - 6 PM

Is this your business?